Five former college editors, and now current journalism professionals and teachers, met to judge the ACP Yearbook Pacemakers in January.

The judges discussed the “must haves” of a Yearbook Pacemaker Finalist. They determined those characteristics were engagement, complete reader service, strong design, strong photography, easy navigation throughout the spread/section, complete campus coverage, community and pertinent state/national coverage and storytelling captions. The judges also said creativity or “out of the box” execution would be considered.

Each judge had a chance to examine each entry. Then, they executed a first cut. After another round, a second cut was made with some discussion regarding whether a book met the criteria to remain as a finalist. After the third round of examining multiple spreads within each section and examining design, photo and copy, the finalists were selected.

The judges discussed each remaining book individually and voted whether the finalist would become a winner.

“This is the first time we’ve had former collegiate editors who are now teachers, magazine designers, and a communication director and owner of a brand and communication agency,” said Laura Widmer, executive director. “The judges gave each entry a long look, and then the discussion amongst them enabled them to pick the best of the best. I thought it was a great process.”

Winners will be announced at the ACP/CMA National College Media Convention in Dallas, Oct. 26-29, 2017. The judges’ comments about each individual finalist and winner will be released at that time.

The 2016 Associated Collegiate Press Yearbook Pacemaker finalists are as follows: